“How are you getting on, Jamie?” De-escalating behaviour challenges in the classroom

Photo by World Sikh Organization of Canada on Pexels.com

Simon’s classroom

Simon’s throat is sore. He has already had to raise his voice several times with 8F this morning, and now he can see Archie turning around again. Once more, he calls across the room.

“Archie, I’ve already told you to stop turning round. That’s a C2, and I’ll be phoning your mum.”

“But Sir…” Archie protests, his voice tinged with frustration and some anxiety. “You’re not meant to phone my mum for a C2.”

Simon strides across the classroom and looms over Archie.

“Stop talking back,” he says, loud enough for the whole class to hear. “That’s a C3, and if you don’t settle down it’ll be a C4. You got the lowest mark on the last assessment. If you don’t concentrate and behave, it’ll happen again.”

As Simon walks away he can hear some students muttering.  He braces himself for the next moment of conflict.

Baldeep’s classroom

Meanwhile, further down the corridor, Baldeep is teaching 8P. He has noticed Jamie beginning to fidget, glancing around the room and starting to turn in his seat. Without interrupting the lesson, Baldeep slowly and deliberately begins circulating. As he moves between tables, he pauses occasionally to glance at pupils’ work and offer a quiet nod of encouragement.

When he reaches Jamie, Baldeep stops and leans casually against the wall nearby, surveying the classroom without making eye contact. He waits for thirty seconds.

Then he crouches down beside the table.

“How are you getting on, Jamie?” he asks quietly. “Having trouble getting started?”

Jamie shrugs.

Baldeep calmly points to the sentence starter on the board. With a sigh, Jamie picks up his pen and begins to write.

“Finish that first sentence and I’ll come back in a minute to help you with the next part,” Baldeep says.

As he stands up, Baldeep gently taps the table behind him, where Sarah has just begun chatting to Molly about her weekend plans.

“That’s a warning, Sarah,” he says quietly.

Then, projecting his voice just enough for others to hear, he addresses Harri.

“Harri, you’ve made so much progress with that paragraph. Great job. I’ll pop a positive point on for you.

Behaviour is rarely improved through public confrontation

Baldeep and Simon could not be more different in the way they deal with pupils who are off task or not meeting their expectations for learning. 

I want to suggest that Baldeep’s approach epitomises a key principle of building an effective learning environment:

When pupils become distracted, off-task, argumentative, or resistant, it is so tempting to tackle the issue head-on in front of the whole class.  Usually this is either driven by our emotional response to the behaviour challenge or a belief that ‘calling it out’ will force pupils into changing their behaviour.   However, public correction creates an audience, and once an audience exists the behaviour of everyone involved in the incident can become more about saving face than making a good decision.  Rather than nipping the problem in the bud, Simon’s approach simply escalates the situation.

In fact, the most effective behaviour management is often barely noticeable. Experienced teachers frequently diffuse potential disruption before it becomes confrontation, redirecting pupils without public conflict and preserving relationships while maintaining expectations.  They know that public criticism can unintentionally escalate situations by inviting pupils to defend themselves, argue, or perform for their peers, so they avoid it.   Public praise, however, is used liberally. 

Why praise matters more than correction

Beginning teachers often underestimate how powerful positive narration can be.  Indeed, one of the easiest ways Simon could have redirected Archie may not have involved speaking to Archie immediately.  Instead, he could have drawn attention to the learning behaviours he wanted to see:

“Thank you, Aisha, for getting straight on with Question 4.”

“Excellent focus from the back row.”

“Tom has already completed the first three responses.”

In many contexts, this public celebration of the desirable behaviours works to give the individual a warm glow of recognition while simultaneously communicating expectations to the whole class and pricking the conscience of those who are not meeting that expectation. Simon could have redirected Archie from his off-task behaviour without any of the negative interaction his more public ‘calling out’ provoked.

Keeping the temperature low by planning your response

Perhaps the most important lesson for beginning teachers is that behaviour management is not a test of strength.  When a pupil becomes distracted, oppositional or argumentative, it can feel as if your authority is being challenged. In those moments it is tempting to raise your voice, issue ultimatums or seek immediate compliance.  But notice that Baldeep did the opposite; he lowered his voice, slowed down, moved closer but without intimidation, gave a clear direction and allowed take-up time.  When Baldeep did give a warning – part of the school’s behaviour policy- it was given quietly and with the intention of getting the pupil back on task.  It’s not that Baldeep avoids managing behaviour, just that he does it in a way that is focused on the behaviour not the individual. 

When teachers personalise behaviour, situations can quickly deteriorate. Sam Strickland (2023, Ch.19) argues that teachers should focus on the behaviour rather than the individual and maintain professional, detached language, even when frustrated. He emphasises the importance of scripting and rehearsing phrases that allow teachers to remain calm, assertive and professional rather than becoming personal or emotional. When teachers depersonalise behaviour and focus on choices and expectations, confrontation becomes less likely and teachers preserve both their authority and professionalism.

Behaviour FOR learning

When I began teaching we talked about ‘behaviour for learning’ a lot. It framed my conception of why we were managing behaviour in our classrooms – my classroom needed to be a place where ALL pupils could learn.

When behaviour difficulties arise, I believe our primary aim should be to return pupils to their learning as quickly and positively as possible. Successful behaviour management is not about calling pupils out or making an example of them for the sake of it, it is about getting them back on track so everyone can continue to learn. Often, a simple prompt, calmly delivered, can be enough to bring about a de-escalation and get a pupil back on task.

Correcting quietly while praising publicly is a powerful technique to achieve this.

References

Strickland, S. (2023). They don’t behave for me: 50 classroom behaviour scenarios to support teachers. John Catt Educational.

Leave a Reply