
Bob sat staring at his laptop. It was 9.30pm. He had opened three lesson plans, two articles he’d been asked to read for his university teaching day, his placement handbook, a half-finished assignment and the assessment records he still needed to update from last week. He’d not made progress on any of them in more than 2 hours. In fact, he had spent most of the evening just switching between them (and occasionally checking his social media). Whenever he sat down to work, he worried about whether he was focusing on the right thing. He spent so much time thinking about how to do a task perfectly that he struggled to begin at all. Lesson planning would lead him to resource making. Resource making would remind him about subject knowledge reading. Subject knowledge reading would make him think about his university assignment. The assignment would bring to mind the marking he still needed to finish. By the end of the evening, he had been busy for hours but had completed very little
Every task felt urgent and important. And every task felt bigger than he could manage. The irony was that Bob cared deeply about becoming a good teacher. He wanted to plan and teach engaging lessons supported by high-quality resources, and provide useful feedback for his pupils. He wanted to complete his university work properly and impress his mentor and his tutor. He wanted to be organised, professional and reliable. But while he wanted to do everything well, he was in fact doing very little at all.
Getting started had always been difficult for Bob. At school and university, he had often found himself putting off assignments until deadlines loomed. Under pressure, he generally managed to get things done but it just wasn’t working now he was training to be a teacher. As the first term of his ITT year had gone on, he just couldn’t keep up; there was always another lesson, class, meeting, email, set of books, assignment and target. He wasn’t meeting deadlines, was forgetting equipment for lessons and was feeling so stressed that some mornings he struggled to get out of bed and go into school at all. How was he supposed to manage all these competing demands?
Most frustrating of all, Bob could see that all these things mattered. He was not looking for excuses; he genuinely valued every element of the course. As he looked around at his fellow trainees, many of them appeared to be coping far better, he wondered what was wrong with him.
The perfectionism-procrastination cycle
What Bob was experiencing is often misunderstood – his procrastination wasn’t the consequence of laziness; it was the consequence of anxiety.
Beginning teachers frequently care enormously about doing things well to the extent that they can find it hard to do anything at all. The fear of producing something that is not good enough can make starting feel risky. As a result, tasks are delayed, creating additional pressure that means the tasks feel even more daunting. And so, the cycle continues.
The result is that highly conscientious mentees can appear disorganised because they care, not because they are unmotivated and lazy. It is not uncommon for beginning teachers like Bob to have incomplete lesson plans, hastily compiled resources, assignments with incomplete reference lists. They are paralysed by their fear of getting it wrong, and so never quite finish. One of the most important lessons beginning teachers like Bob need to learn is that teaching is a profession where ‘good enough’ is often far more useful than ‘perfect but late’.
There is no finishing line
Another challenge the confronts novice teachers such as Bob, is that teaching presents an endless supply of potentially worthwhile tasks. Unlike revision for an examination, there is rarely a moment when everything is complete. The goal therefore is not to finish everything, rather it is about identifying what matters most today. This might sound obvious, but it requires a significant shift in thinking. Bob’s development into a teaching professional will be achieved by learning to make sensible decisions about where to invest his limited time and attention. He needs to understand that steadily working through a prioritised to do list is much more useful than having hundreds of tabs open on his computer in one go.
What helped Bob
Bob’s situation did not improve overnight, and no magic solution appeared. Instead, he began making a series of small but important changes.
First, and perhaps most importantly, he spoke honestly with his mentor and tutor about how overwhelmed he was feeling. They worked with him to come up with a plan to help him move forward. They helped him identify the groups on his timetable for whom he was going to stop rewriting lesson plans and making new resources when those that already existed were fit for purpose. They helped him to identify the best group to keep as the class for whom he would plan from first principles to ensure he continued to make progress in his thinking about structuring sequences for progression. They helped him develop approaches to live marking so he could help pupils improve their work in the moment. They helped him to approach lessons with adaptive teaching built in meaning he no longer made bespoke worksheets for individual pupils.
Secondly his tutor helped him set up a work planner. Each period of the day, including morning briefing and afterschool meetings, was added to the planner. Specific time-defined tasks were allocated to his PPA slots and a before and after school to-do list created with guidance for how to prioritise tasks. This helped him to begin identifying three priority tasks each day rather than attempting twenty. He also started using his phone calendar to set reminders and used the timer to put a time limit on tasks that he knew should take 20 minutes not 2 hours.
Thirdly, his mentor started holding him to the original requirement to hand in lesson plans 48 hours in advance. This meant he could get feedback on a rough outline and get feedback before developing it fully for teaching – this really helped to cut down the workload because he stopped making something to have to begin again once his mentor pointed out why it might not work in reality.
Finally, he started to think about his day differently. The 40 minutes on the bus had been dead time where he would sit looking out of the window and feeling stressed. His tutor pointed him in the direction of some podcasts to listen to on the journey, and he realised he could download audiobooks from the library, which helped him develop his subject knowledge which cut down his planning time as he started planning from a much more informed position.
Gradually, the fog began to lift and, while the work and competing demands did not disappear, it became more manageable because Bob had asked for help and was determined to work with his mentor and tutor to learn and make progress in this area.
You and Bob
If Bob’s story feels familiar, either because you are a bit of a Bob or are supporting a Bob-like mentee, it is worth remembering that this happens to a lot of beginning teachers and is part of the professionalism learning curve that takes place during initial teacher education. Many beginning teachers feel that struggling with workload means they are failing but they are just learning how to prioritise a teacher workload.
If Bobs find themselves drowning rather than waving, it is so important they feel able to speak to somebody. Mentors, university tutors and colleagues would much rather help them navigate the challenges of training than watch them struggle silently. Teachers need these skills and they will need to develop them but it’s ok to have to learn how to do that.
Other blogs you may find helpful